CO129-120 - Sir MacDonnell - 1867 [1-2] — Page 124

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

2.

I notice that Your Lordship disapproves of Section 15 of that Ordinance on the ground that branding can be justified only in rare cases, where it may be of vital importance to be able to identify a Criminal, but Her Majesty's Government cannot sanction it as a punishment.

3. I am very anxious that before Your Lordship arrives at a final decision in a matter of such extreme importance, you should have before you my despatch No. 160 of the 23rd last November, announcing the state of the Gaol at Stone Cutters' Island, and entering very fully into the whole subject of the position of this colony unavoidably brought, as it is, face to face with such a moving mass of Crime and vagabondage, caused by its immediate proximity to millions of the worst population of the Chinese Empire.

I apprehend that no description can more fully point out the necessity for adopting means of identifying Offenders than Your Lordship's definition that they should only be employed where it may be of vital importance to be able to identify a "Criminal". And that it should "not be sanctioned as a punishment."

5. I would respectfully suggest that Paragraphs 8, 9, 10, and 11, together with...

Edit History

2026-05-19 15:35:58 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
2.I notice that Your Lordship disapproves of Section 15 of that Ordinance on the ground that branding can be justified only in rare cases, where it may be of vital importance to be able to identify a Criminal, but Her Majesty's Government cannot sanction it as a punishment.3. I am very anxious that before Your Lordship arrives at a final decision in a matter of such extreme importance, you should have before you my despatch No. 160 of the 23rd last November, announcing the state of the Gaol at Stone Cutters' Island, and entering very fully into the whole subject of the position of this colony unavoidably brought, as it is, face to face with such a moving mass of Crime and vagabondage, caused by its immediate proximity to millions of the worst population of the Chinese Empire.I apprehend that no description can more fully point out the necessity for adopting means of identifying Offenders than Your Lordship's definition that they should only be employed where it may be of vital importance to be able to identify a "Criminal". And that it should "not be sanctioned as a punishment."5. I would respectfully suggest that Paragraphs 8, 9, 10, and 11, together with...
Baseline (Original)
2.ல்2.I notice that Your Sordshipbranding & bloggingمنتقد&>it asH.I##dis approves of Section 15 of that Ordinance onbrandingvery the ground that can be justified only" inwhere it may rare cases, where it be of vital importance to be able to identify a Criminal, but Her Majestip'sment cannot sanction Government co a3. punishment. I am very anxious that before Your Lordship arrives at a final decision in a matter of such extreme importance, you should have before you my despatch No 16o of the 23rd last November, announcing the the present of the Gaol at Stone butter's Island, and entering very3122 fully into the whole subject of the position of this bolony unavoidably brought, as it is, face to face with such a moving mass of Crime and vagabondage, caused by its immediate proximity to millions of the worst population of the Chinese Compire. apprehend that no can moredescription fully point out the necefaity for adopting means of identifying Offenders than Your Lorship's definition that they should only be employed whereN iti may be of vital importance to be able to identify Criminal". And that it should "not be sanctioned as a 180 6051closing for am 28.4punishment."5. I would respectfully suggest that Paragraphs 8, 9, 10, +11 together with
2026-05-19 15:35:58 · Baseline
View content

2.

ல்

2.

I notice that Your Sordship

branding & blogging

منتقد

&

>

it as

H.

I

#

#

dis approves of Section 15 of that

Ordinance on

branding

very

the

ground

that

can be justified only" in

where it may

rare cases, where it

be of

vital importance to be able to identify

a Criminal, but Her Majestip's

ment cannot sanction

Government co

a

3.

punishment.

I am very anxious that before Your Lordship arrives at

a

final

decision in a matter of such extreme

importance, you should have before you

my despatch No 16o of the 23rd last

November,

announcing

the

the present of the Gaol at Stone

butter's Island, and entering very

3

122

fully into the whole subject of the position of this bolony unavoidably brought, as it is, face to face with such

a

moving mass of Crime and

vagabondage, caused by its immediate proximity to

millions of the worst population of the Chinese Compire.

apprehend that no

can more

description

fully point out the necefaity

for adopting

means

of identifying Offenders

than Your Lorship's definition that

they should only be employed where

N

it

i

may

be of vital importance to be able

to identify

Criminal". And that it

should "not be sanctioned as a

180 6051

closing for am 28.4

punishment."

5.

I would respectfully suggest

that

Paragraphs 8, 9, 10, +11

together with

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.